Fantasy Island

About This Property

Welcome to Fantasy Island, a truly special Lake of the Woods retreat tucked into the natural beauty of Pine Portage Bay. Just a short boat ride from mainland docking, this 1.86-acre island offers the rare combination of convenience, privacy, timeless character, and exceptional pride of ownership.

Surrounded by deep water on all sides and owned to the high-water mark, the island features approximately 1,324 feet of shoreline and an unforgettable park-like setting of old growth red pines and cedars. Meandering pathways, granite outcroppings, quiet sitting areas, and thoughtfully maintained grounds create a sense of peace and permanence that is increasingly difficult to find.

Cherished by the same family since 1979, Fantasy Island has been lovingly cared for and thoughtfully improved over generations. The original cottage, believed to date back to the 1950s, offers 3 beds and 1 bath with approximately 850 sq ft of warm and welcoming living space filled with the charm and nostalgia of classic summers at the lake. It is a place where children and grandchildren have gathered, memories have been made, and traditions have been carried forward for decades.

In 2005, the owners completed a beautifully crafted 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom four-season lake home on the south side of the island. Designed in a timeless craftsman style, this custom build reflects a deep understanding and appreciation of lake living, with countless thoughtful details and quality finishes that seasoned cottagers will immediately recognize and appreciate.

Fully serviced with 200-amp hydro and a full septic system connected to both buildings, the property is exceptionally well equipped and move-in ready for year-round enjoyment.

Fantasy Island is more than just a property. It is a place that has been deeply loved, carefully stewarded, and genuinely enjoyed. Opportunities to own an island of this calibre, in such a protected and convenient location, are few and far between.